Small Pet Select is a hay brand sold mainly online that markets its hay as fresher and greener than typical pet-store options. Its 2nd cutting timothy is especially popular with rabbit and guinea pig owners. This review looks at what the product offers and what to weigh before you buy.
The Short Answer: Small Pet Select Timothy Hay is a popular choice for owners who want fresh, leafy hay delivered to the door. Many owners report it’s greener and more appealing than some bagged hays, but it typically costs more than local bulk hay, and like all natural hay, quality can vary between batches.
Key Details
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| Hay type | Timothy grass hay |
| Cuttings offered | 1st, 2nd and 3rd cutting (availability varies) |
| Suitable for | Rabbits, guinea pigs, chinchillas |
| Sold mainly | Online, with subscription options |
| Packaging | Boxes in several sizes |
What It Is and How It Works
Hay cuttings differ by harvest timing:
- 1st cutting: coarser, more stems and seed heads, highest fiber
- 2nd cutting: balance of stems and leaves, softer texture, most popular
- 3rd cutting: very soft and leafy, lower fiber, often used for picky eaters
Small Pet Select ships hay in boxes, which can reduce crushing compared with bags. Many owners choose a 2nd cutting as a daily staple.
For more on why hay matters, see our ideal rabbit diet guide and rabbit dental disease.
What We Like
- Several cuttings to suit different pets
- Often described as green and fragrant
- Shipped in boxes, which can protect texture
- Subscription delivery is convenient
- Suitable for multiple herbivore species
Drawbacks
- Usually costs more than local bulk hay
- Shipping times and costs vary by location
- Batch-to-batch variation, as with all hay
- Third cutting alone may be too low in fiber for some pets
Cost Comparison
Prices change often, but here’s how options typically compare per pound:
| Source | Typical cost per pound | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Local farm or feed store bales | Lowest | Requires storage space and pickup |
| Large online boxes (like Small Pet Select) | Moderate | Delivered; subscription discounts may apply |
| Small pet-store bags | Highest | Convenient but costly over time |
A single rabbit or pair of guinea pigs can go through several pounds of hay a week, so bulk options often save money over a year.
Things to Consider Before Buying
- Choose 1st or 2nd cutting for daily feeding, since higher fiber supports teeth and digestion.
- Compare the cost per pound with local feed stores or farms.
- Store boxes in a dry, ventilated spot once opened.
- Introduce a new hay gradually by mixing it with the old one.
- Check each box for mold, excess dust or a musty smell.
Who It Suits
| Good fit if… | Consider something else if… |
|---|---|
| You want fresh hay delivered | You have access to good local hay for less |
| You have a picky eater who prefers softer hay | You need hay immediately |
| You like choosing a specific cutting | You’re on a tight budget |
Alternatives to Consider
| Option | How it differs |
|---|---|
| Oxbow Western Timothy Hay | Widely available in stores |
| Local farm or feed store hay | Often cheapest in bulk |
| Orchard grass or meadow hay | Different textures for variety |
When to Call Your Vet
Contact your vet if:
- Your pet suddenly refuses hay
- You notice weight loss, drooling or dropped food
- Droppings shrink or stop
Frequently Asked Questions
Which cutting is best?
2nd cutting is a popular daily choice. 1st cutting is great for fiber; 3rd cutting can tempt picky eaters but shouldn’t be the only hay for most pets.
Is Small Pet Select hay organic?
Check current product listings, since certifications and sourcing can change.
How long does an opened box last?
Store it dry and use it within a few months for best freshness.
Can guinea pigs eat the same hay as rabbits?
Yes. Timothy hay suits both.
What if the hay is dusty?
Shake it outdoors and contact the seller if a box seems unusually dusty or moldy.
Is it worth paying more for hay?
If your pet eats more hay because it’s fresher, the benefits for teeth and digestion can be worth it. Compare cost per pound and your pet’s response.
Can I order a sample?
Some sellers offer small boxes or variety packs to test before committing.
Does Small Pet Select sell other hays?
Yes, including orchard grass and other blends. Availability changes, so check current listings.
Pet Health Man is independent and isn’t paid by the brands we review. Product formulas, specifications and prices change, so check the current label or the manufacturer’s information before you buy.
This article is for general information only and isn’t a substitute for professional veterinary advice. If you’re worried about your pet’s health, contact your veterinarian or an emergency animal hospital.
